First, a quick recap: The theatrical version (124 min) follows Salvatore "Toto" Di Vita, a famous filmmaker, as he returns to his Sicilian village after learning of the death of his old friend, Alfredo, the cinema’s projectionist. Through flashbacks, we see Toto grow from a mischievous boy into a lovestruck teen. The film concludes with Alfredo’s funeral and the famous gift—a reel of film containing every censored kiss ever cut from movies. It’s perfect.

Critics and fans remain deeply divided on which version is superior.

The theatrical cut is the memory of a boy. It is pure, filtered through amber light and Ennio Morricone’s swelling score.